The MW DeskData center power, space & people

THE MW DESK / BLOG

8 min readpolicy · transparency · land · entitlement · New Jersey

New Jersey Just Followed the Secret to the Land Deal

Senate Bill 4304 would ban data-center NDAs with planning boards and land sellers, and force applicants to attest that no concealment deal exists. The Senate passed it 38-0. The secret we said had moved upstream just got written into a bill.

Two days after we wrote that the NDA was dying and the secret had moved to the land deal, New Jersey’s Senate handed that argument a piece of paper.

Senate Bill 4304 would bar data-center applicants and their agents from using NDAs (including with planning boards, municipal agencies and property sellers) to conceal a project or keep it out of public review. It calls those agreements “against public policy and unenforceable.” Boards could not approve a site plan or subdivision if the applicant violates the rule. And the applicant would have to attest that no concealment deal was made with the seller (DCD; NJ Legislature).

The Senate passed it 38-0 on October 22, with two abstentions. It is now in the Assembly’s Science, Innovation and Technology Committee (DCD; NJ Legislature). It is not law yet. It is already a map of where the fight moved.

What the bill actually closes

Corporate pledges closed one door. Microsoft, Amazon and OpenAI have all said they will stop using NDAs with public officials for data-center projects (Microsoft; WIRED; OpenAI). Microsoft was also clear about what it kept: NDAs for private land acquisitions (WPR).

That is the window S4304 aims at.

Most transparency bills and executive orders stop at the government signature. They tell a county commissioner or a state agency not to lock themselves into silence. New Jersey’s draft goes one step further and names the seller. If an applicant cannot put a seller under an NDA, and must attest that no concealment deal exists, the quiet period between controlling dirt and filing a public application gets a lot shorter, and a lot riskier to paper over.

Senator Linda Greenstein, a lead sponsor, put the politics plainly: “Transparency is crucial during the data center development process, especially since these projects can have a major impact on our communities.” Senator Brian Stack added that residents “deserve to know what is being proposed in their neighborhoods” (DCD).

Read that as underwriting language, not just a press quote. The political product counties now sell to voters is visibility. A bill that makes seller-side silence unenforceable is how that product gets written into the approval path.

Why the seller clause is the whole story

On November 7 we argued that the remaining private piece of the process was the land window: control the site first, disclose later. S4304 is what happens when a legislature follows that window upstream.

Three practical changes fall out of a seller ban plus an attestation, if the Assembly passes it and a governor signs it.

First, the option agreement changes. Quiet purchase options and NDAs that keep a landowner from talking to neighbors, reporters or competing buyers become a compliance problem, not a clever structuring tool. Brokers and site selectors who built a book on “we cannot tell you who it is” will need a new pitch.

Second, the attestation creates a paper trail. An applicant who swears no concealment deal exists, then gets caught with one, is not in a PR spat. They are in a permitting fight with a written statement on file. That is a different risk register.

Third, the middle of the chain gets squeezed again. WIRED documented how end tenants are often not the ones signing local NDAs: contractors and advisors are (WIRED). S4304 reaches “applicants and agents.” If that language holds, the contractor NDA that sat under a hyperscaler’s public transparency pledge is exactly what the bill is aiming at.

New Jersey is not a fringe market for this. DCD notes a sizable Garden State footprint centered on Newark and Secaucus spillover from New York, with operators already present and new capacity still trying to land, while many localities have already put moratoriums or bans in place (DCD). A transparency rule on top of local friction is not abstract. It is a delivery constraint.

This goes beyond New Jersey

S4304 is the sharpest state draft we have seen on the seller side. It is not the only place secrecy is getting rewritten.

California already enacted a different kind of limit. SB 994, signed September 27, 2026 as Chapter 669, voids certain local-official NDAs entered on or after January 1, 2027 that stop an official from sharing information with fellow officials on the same body (LCW; Eckland & Blando). It is not a data-center-specific seller ban. It is a board-room ban: one member cannot be locked into silence that the rest of the dais cannot hear. That matters for how closed-door site pitches work in California cities and counties, with carve-outs for trade secrets and for NDAs authorized by a unanimous governing-body vote (LCW).

Elsewhere the map is uneven but crowded. A October 2026 state-by-state review by Eckland & Blando flags Pennsylvania Executive Order 2026-05 limiting executive-agency data-center NDAs, Virginia Executive Order 22 doing the same for executive-branch agencies, proposed bills in Michigan, Ohio and Pennsylvania, a failed North Dakota Senate vote, failed Wisconsin bills, and local action in places such as South Bend, Indiana (Eckland & Blando). New Jersey’s prior seller-side proposal died at the end of the last session; S4304 is the rematch (Eckland & Blando).

The pattern is not “every state banned secrecy.” The pattern is “the places that still treat silence as normal are becoming the exception, and the bills are getting more precise about who cannot be silenced.”

Capital, labor and real estate all feel it

Capital. Lenders and equity already price entitlement risk. A regime where seller NDAs are unenforceable and attestations sit in the file turns “quiet control” into a diligence question. Sponsors who can show a clean disclosure trail will clear faster than sponsors whose story depends on nobody asking how the dirt was locked up. That favors balance sheets that can survive a public process, the same split we keep seeing when existing powered capacity outperforms speculative land assemblies.

Labor and community politics. OpenAI’s public compact already pointed at published job forecasts and apprenticeship plans as part of the disclosure package (OpenAI). When the land deal itself cannot stay dark, those labor promises show up earlier in the local fight, which means electrician and craft shortages become visible before the shovel, not after.

Real estate product. The product that wins is land that can go public without a panic: zoning that does not need a surprise hearing, neighbors who were not blindsided, and a paper trail that matches what the tenant already promised the internet. Opaque assemblage still happens. It just carries a fatter political and legal tail.

Transparent listing boards are not a moral preference in that world. They are a matching tool. When concealment deals are harder to enforce, buyers and sellers need a place to find each other in the open (with flat fees, not a quiet 15% channel cut), which is exactly why we built the development sites desk as a board, not a brokerage.

Why it matters for builders, buyers and investors

Builders and developers: Assume seller-side NDAs become a template other states copy. Rewrite option agreements now. If your competitive edge was “the county finds out last,” stress-test the schedule against an attestation requirement and a board that cannot approve you if you lie.

Buyers and tenants: Your public NDA pledge is only as good as your agents’ paperwork. Ask, in writing, whether anyone in your site-selection chain signed a seller or municipal confidentiality deal that S4304-style language would void. A clean file is a product feature.

Investors: Watch the Assembly committee, then watch copycat bills. Underwrite New Jersey (and any state that follows) as a market where the land window is shorter and disclosure is part of the entitlement package. Platforms priced on quiet control deserve a harder look. $MSFT and $AMZN already published government-NDA pledges; the open question is whether their land and contractor stacks match the statute that is coming.

What to watch

Not investment advice.

Sources

  1. https://njleg.state.nj.us/bill-search/2026/S4304 ↗
  2. https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/new-jersey-senate-passes-bill-banning-data-center-related-ndas/ ↗
  3. https://www.ecklandblando.com/blog/2026/10/state-by-state-overview-nda-restrictions-for-local-officials/ ↗
  4. https://www.lcwlegal.com/news/sb-994-restricts-certain-nondisclosure-agreements-involving-local-agency-officials/ ↗
  5. https://local.microsoft.com/blog/putting-communities-first-our-decision-to-end-ndas-with-local-governments/ ↗
  6. https://www.wpr.org/news/microsoft-to-stop-using-ndas-with-local-governments-for-data-center-development ↗
  7. https://www.wired.com/story/amazon-says-it-is-going-to-stop-using-ndas-for-data-centers/ ↗
  8. https://openai.com/index/setting-new-standard-responsible-ai-infrastructure ↗
  9. https://themwdesk.com/blog/the-secret-moved-to-the-land-deal/ ↗

Report a problem with this page ↗